Fijishi Juris

Forensic case support when an AI decision is disputed: what the rule required, set against what the record shows the system did.

What Juris answers

For one AI decision in dispute, working to the instructions of licensed counsel acting for a firm, Juris answers four questions from the record:

  • which rule bound the decision, as counsel names it, and what it required of the firm - for example a human review, an explanation, or a way to override;
  • what the record shows the system actually did: its inputs, the version running that day, its output, and any review or override, with who and when;
  • whether the decision could have been stopped, and by whom;
  • which parts of that record will hold up, which will not, and what the record cannot show at all.

The matter may be before a court, a tribunal, an arbitration or a regulatory proceeding, or not yet begun. It may involve a Fijishi Certification finding, or none.

Where Juris fits beside counsel and other experts

Counsel knows the law. A data scientist or a forensic accountant can rebuild a model or trace a loss, and may already be on the matter. Juris does the part between them: it sets each element of the rule against what the record shows the system did, decision by decision, using the same method as every Fijishi finding and the jurisdiction research published in the Fijishi Jurisdiction Index. It works alongside other experts on the matter, not in place of them.

Fijishi sells no insurance or other financial products, builds or sells no AI and does no consulting work, so it has no system of its own, and no client's build, to defend.

What counsel receives

One written case file, signed by both founders, containing:

  • A chronology of the decision, from the record, with the source of each entry;
  • The rule against the record: each element of the rule counsel names, with what the record shows, what it does not, and the evidence for each;
  • An evidence register: each record relied on, where it came from, who holds it, and how its integrity was checked;
  • One decision reconstructed end to end, where the records allow it;
  • What the record cannot show, and which further records would answer it.

Before the case file, counsel receives an initial view of what the records can and cannot show, normally within ten business days of receiving them. See the example case file below.

Who does the work

Both founders, Akhil Sharma and Preethi Sharma, examine the records and sign every case file. They have worked on decision systems in regulated financial services since 2010 and 2015 - in capital markets, banking, insurance, reinsurance and claims, including systems that used AI models - and on the controls, compliance, audit and regulatory requirements around them (Founders). Fijishi never works on a matter about a system either founder worked on as a consultant. The method is the one published in How a finding is decided: records before documents, samples stated, one decision end to end, two sign-offs, never one.

Juris's role in a matter

Juris works for instructing counsel as a non-testifying expert. Its work goes to counsel, who decides how it is used, including any question of privilege or protection, under the law of the forum. At present Juris does not give expert evidence in court.

Juris does not practise law. It does not give legal advice, does not give a view on liability, the merits or damages, does not appear as counsel of record and does not represent any party.

Where a matter involves a Fijishi Certification finding, Juris works from the finding as issued; it does not revise it.

Firewall

Juris does not accept an engagement adverse to a current Fijishi client, or one that challenges a finding Fijishi issued for that client.

Juris does not accept an engagement against a company named in a Fijishi Index entry on the subject of that entry.

These are standing policies, applied before any engagement is considered (Governance).

Fee and timing

The fee is fixed when the matter is instructed, for the scope agreed in writing, before any work begins. It is not hourly, and it does not depend on the outcome of the matter. The first conversation has no fee. The timetable is set to the matter's deadlines and confirmed when Juris is instructed. How Juris works, step by step.

Example case file - illustrative, not a client matter

This example is hypothetical. The insurer, the claim, the rule, the system and every record below are invented to show what a Juris case file looks like. It describes no real firm, claim or matter, and it is not legal advice.

FIJISHI JURIS CASE FILE (EXAMPLE)

Matter: a policyholder challenges the decline of a home water-damage claim, saying no person reviewed it.
Instructed by: counsel for the insurer (fictional).
Rule named by counsel: a rule in force in the insurer's jurisdiction requiring that a claim be declined only by a person who has reviewed the claim file, and that the decline letter give the reasons.
Question from counsel: what does the record show about how this decline was made?

Records received

  • the claim file and the decline letter;
  • the system's decision log for the claim (score, recommendation, model version, time), held by the vendor;
  • the claims system's audit trail of what the handler opened, and the handler's notes;
  • the vendor's model change log and the relevant part of the vendor contract;
  • the claims procedure in force on the date.

Chronology (from the record)

  • 3 March, 09:12 - claim submitted online with photographs and a repair quote [claim file].
  • 09:13 - the system scores the claim and recommends a decline, model version 4.2 [vendor decision log].
  • 09:40 - a claims handler opens the recommendation screen [audit trail].
  • 09:41 - the handler confirms the decline; the audit trail shows no photograph or quote was opened [audit trail].
  • 4 March - decline letter sent, giving a decline code [decline letter].
  • 18 March - the vendor updates the model to version 4.3 [vendor change log].
  • 2 April - the policyholder complains [claim file].

The rule against the record

  • A person declined the claim. Shown: a named handler confirmed the decline, one minute after opening the recommendation [audit trail].
  • That person reviewed the claim file. Not shown: the audit trail records no photograph, quote or note opened before the decline; the handler's note reads only "agree with system".
  • The letter gave the reasons. Not shown: the letter gives a decline code, not reasons; the code's meaning is in the vendor's documentation, not in the letter.

Could the decision have been stopped?

Yes, for this claim: the handler could reject the recommendation, and the audit trail shows that handlers did so in other claims that week. Declines could not be suspended as a whole without a request to the vendor [vendor contract].

What will hold up, and what will not

  • The vendor's decision log is append-only, and three of its entries match the insurer's own claims system to the second: it is likely to hold up.
  • The handler's notes can be edited after the event, and the system keeps no history of edits: they carry less weight than the audit trail.

What the record cannot show

  • Whether the handler looked at the photographs elsewhere, for example on another screen. An interview, which is for counsel to decide on, could answer it.
  • How version 4.2 weighed the repair quote. The vendor holds the model's configuration for that version; the contract gives the insurer a right to request it.

Signed: both founders (example). This case file states what the record shows. It gives no view on liability, the merits or damages, which are for counsel and the tribunal.

This example is hypothetical and describes no real firm, claim or matter.

Worth knowing about before you need it

Counsel and risk teams are welcome to write simply to understand what Juris does. No engagement is expected or solicited from that conversation, and it has no fee.

Start an engagement

Counsel on a matter: write to protocol@fijishi.com with the parties, the AI decision in dispute, the forum and any deadline. We run the conflicts check first and tell you within two business days whether we can act. Other enquiries are answered within 5 business days. How Juris works